Catholics Leave Mass Over Bigoted Homily, but Not All Priests Oppose Marriage Equality

Gaelic footballer Eámon McGee, left, supporting the ‘Yes’ campaign

Catholics in Ireland walked out of Mass recently after a priest made prejudiced and personal attacks during a homily against marriage equality, about which the Irish are set to vote in a referendum later this spring.

Fr. John Britto, a Carmelite from India, encouraged parishioners at St. Mary Star of the Sea Church in Annagry, County Donegal, to deny same-gender couples the right to marry by voting ‘No.’ He also attacked local Gaelic footballer Eamon McGee, who has publicly supported the ‘Yes’ campaign, recently telling the Irish Examiner:

” ‘I don’t know would I be more ashamed that I didn’t vote or the fact I voted against it. It comes down to equality and one less difference in society…It’s not that I have any friends who are gay or any close family members but it’s a social issue.’ “

In response to Fr. Britto’s homily, more than a dozen attendees stood up and walked out, including family members of the woman for whom Mass was being offered on the first anniversary of her death. One parishioner who left told The Independent:

” ‘He (the priest) is entitled to his view but it didn’t go down well. After the Mass some members of the congregation approached the family of the woman being remembered to say they only stayed because of them, otherwise they would have walked out too.’ “

Former altar boy and longtime parishioner Noel Sharkey, who assists the ‘Yes’ campaign there also commented:

” ‘As a Catholic and a gay man from the area, I think it’s essential that we engage on this issue in a respectful and tolerant way, and I ask people to avoid using hurtful or upsetting language. Yes Equality Donegal asks people to focus their attention on the key principles of love and equality as they make their mind up on this important issue.’ “

Fr. Britto, however, denies these claims and refuses to clarify what happened, saying only:

“I didn’t see anybody leaving. I didn’t see that…I won’t talk to the media because the media will only twist what I have to say; I speak to the people in church and I only the speak the truth and the Word of God.”

It was reported that the priest issued an apology to McGee, but Fr. Britto denies apologizing for any of his homily, reports The Independent.

Fr. Iggy O’Donovan

On a slightly more positive note, an Augustinian priest from County Limerick announced he would vote ‘Yes’ in the referendum. Fr. Iggy O’Donovan wrote an op-ed for the Irish Times in which he stated:

” ‘It is possible to have deep and passionately-held convictions without seeking to have those convictions imposed by the State on fellow citizens who do not share them…respect for the freedom of others who differ from us is part and parcel of the faith we profess. For these and for other reasons I will be voting Yes.’ “

In a later radio interview, Fr. O’Donovan clarified that he does not endorse marriage equality and would never preside at a same-gender wedding, but he could not judge others and how they choose to live their lives. He ventured that other priests would likely vote ‘Yes,’ too.

With about ten weeks until Irish polls open, the ‘Yes’ campaign is launched and the debate over marriage equality is intensifying.

The damage by negative statements from church leaders such as Fr. John Britto or Bishop Kevin Doran, who said gay couples were not parents and compared homosexuality to Down syndrome, is enormous. Catholic clergy would do well to temper their anti-LGBT viewpoints, which are increasingly not accepted by an Irish Church already devastated due to the sexual abuse crisis and other problems, and keep these thoughts out of Mass. If they wish to make their opinions known on the issue, like Fr. Iggy O’Donovan, doing so in another venue, and in a way that is respectful of and sensitive to LGBT people, should be the foremost considerations.

Marriage equality coming to Ireland could be a moment of renewed belief in marriage, love, and family in this traditionally very Catholic nation. Church leaders should choose to prevent divisive pastoral harm in the lead up to the referendum.

–Bob Shine, New Ways Ministry

9 replies
  1. Friends
    Friends says:

    Following up: here’s an item about this outrageous situation, from an Irish press source — and it includes a photo of the foreign priest who made those hateful comments:

    Frankly, this has happened before — where priests from Africa, or parts of Asia, have been assigned to Western countries, and have brought the extremely reactionary cultural values of their home countries to their new priestly assignments in Europe or the United States. Bondings 2.0 has covered several of these “foreign priest” incidents in the past.

    Really, this should not be happening. All it does, as in this case, is to infuriate and alienate the otherwise loyal and devoted Catholics in Western countries — who simply will not put up with this sort of arrogant and ignorant cultural bigotry being expressed by some African or Asian priests. We continue to hope that Pope Francis himself will finally intervene, and put an end to this sort of anti-pastoral cultural malpractice.

  2. Cuspis P O'Leary
    Cuspis P O'Leary says:

    Whenever anyone has such strong reactions to gay people, you can ALWAYS assume he is a self loathing closeted homosexual! ALWAYS!!! I MEAN ALWAYS.

  3. Haydn Tormey
    Haydn Tormey says:

    A congregation with a philosophy that lacks a priesthood, and a priesthood with a philosophy that lacks a congregation, welded & bolted together out of convenience, to form the Frankenstein monster that is contemporary Catholicism.
    It is inevitable that limbs will occasionally drop off.

  4. freecatholic808
    freecatholic808 says:

    Reblogged this on Dawn Morais and commented:
    Systemic, structural inequalities, elected Catholic “leaders” like John Boehner and Paul Ryan whose policies benefit big business at the expense of the poor, bigotry from the bench (like the pronouncements of Catholic Supreme Court judge, Antonin Scalia), public officials (like Catholic governor Bobby Jindal in Louisiana who withhold healthcare from the poor and needy),hypocrisy from thrice-married Catholic convert,Newt Gingrich, Catholic politicians who vote AGAINST pay parity for women or raising the minimum wage so people make enough to feed their families: at home and abroad, there is no shortage of issues that call for the clergy to forcefully remind us what Jesus taught us. People in the pews would welcome a return to the Gospel of justice Jesus left us and the retirement of diatribes on sexual behavior.

  5. Friends
    Friends says:

    Pointedly but alarmingly relevant: Irish Catholic writer John Boyne discusses the horrific symbiosis between extreme sexual repression, and the extreme covert sexual exploitation of children, in the Irish Church where he was raised:

    It’s not easy to listen to — but it’s directly pertinent to the discussion threads posted here. The interview was broadcast this weekend on the Canadian CBC’s excellent and always-provocative “Sunday Edition” program. Host Michael Enright was himself raised as a Catholic, and educated by nuns, FWIW!


Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. […] commentary, campaigning and speeches were made. To such extent that members of congregations walked out of masses and some leaving permanently. Calls to LGBT helplines did increase from some of the rhetoric from […]

  2. […] is the strength of public support from the clergy and religious women. Throughout the campaign, clergy and religious women have been more vocal in their endorsement of marriage equality than in […]

  3. […] Fr. Iggy O’Donovan wrote a pro-marriage equality article, saying “respect for the freedom of others who differ […]

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *