Priest Punished for Promoting Letter Writing Campaign Against Anti-LGBTQ Bishop

Fr. Pawel Gużyński

A priest in Poland has been punished for publicly criticizing a top archbishop who referred to the campaign for LGBTQ equality as a “rainbow disease.” A war of words has erupted in Poland, with advocates for both clergymen making statements.

Earlier this month, Dominican Fr. Pawel Gużyński encouraged Catholics to write Krakow’s Archbishop Marek Jedraszewski and ask him to resign over the archbishop’s harsh comments against LGBTQ people. But now Gużyński’s provincial, Fr. Pawl Kozacki, has apparently punished Gużyński by sending the priest on a multi-week penitential silent retreat so he can “find the right way for a clergyman to speak on matters of faith and morals and to conduct ideological disputes,” reported Polsat News.

Gużyński’s call for the archbishop’s resignation was posted on Facebook August 4th, three days after Jedraszewski compared LGBTQ advocates to Poland’s oppressive Communist government. The Dominican priest appealed online:

“When I was an Amnesty International activist many years ago, we sent letters to various institutions around the world regarding persecuted people to create constant pressure. We did it for as long as the case did not find any meaningful end.

“I suggest that we start sending letters tomorrow to Archbishop Jędraszewski with the expectation that he will resign honorably because of his words about the ‘rainbow disease’.

“I don’t mean a church rebellion!!! If we do it together, consistently and with due respect for the office of a bishop, it will at least have the strength of our decency. Such is our Catholic letter writing marathon.

“Our own passivity destroys us, which is why I start tomorrow, one letter or e-mail a week until the end (even if I’m the only one).”

Another priest, Fr. Andrzej Szostek, was likewise outspoken against the archbishop. Szostek noted TVN 24 that Jędraszewski failed to condemn the violence inflicted on Pride marchers in Bialystok last month when police had to intervene against right-wing attackers. The priest commented:

“There wasn’t a single word on it. One word about this event, this scandal, what I think was not only deeply anti-human, but also deeply anti-Christian. What those who attacked members of the Equality March did was hit the Lord Jesus on the cheek. This is introducing the Trojan horse to the Church. . .Jesus is open to everyone. For him there are no strangers, no enemies, no one to turn his back on, no one to attack. They want to justify this kind of action in the name of Christianity? This is more than a scandal for me.”

Opposition to Jędraszewski’s comments was also voiced during a rally outside the Apostolic Nunciature in Krakow where protesters called for the Catholic Church to reform itself not only on LGBTQ issues, but on clergy sexual abuse. One critic, law professor Monika Platek, even suggested the archbishop had broken the law in making anti-LGBTQ comments.

But many church leaders in Poland are defending Jędraszewski, with some adding their own salvos against LGBTQ equality. Archbishop Stanisław Gądecki of Poznań released an August 8th statement calling on people to not discriminate against opponents of LGBTQ equality amid this summer’s tensions, reported Crux. Gądecki, who heads the Polish Bishops’ Conference, wrote, in part:

“Hence my appeal to local authorities not to make decisions that – under the guise of counteracting discrimination – would conceal the ideology that denies the natural gender difference and complementarity between men and women. I also appeal to parliamentarians to resist the far-reaching plans of LGBT+ milieus, that aim to change Polish law in order to introduce the so-called “homosexual marriage” and the possibility of adoption children by them.

“The wave of criticism that affected the Metropolitan of Cracow, the archbishop and professor, as well as the reactions of employers towards people expressing their disapproval of LGBT+ ideology, testify to the ideological totalitarianism rooted in certain milieus, consisting in removing people who think differently outside the sphere of freedom. Therefore, I appeal to all people of good will to apply the principle of non-discrimination in public discussion not only to the supporters of the mentioned ideology, but also to allow its opponents on equal rights to debate.”

Bishop Miroslaw Milewski, an auxiliary of Plock, described Pride marches in a homily as “immoral” and composed of “ungodly people,” reported MSNMilewski warned that Catholics must protect themselves from “sick LGBT ideology.” He offered a Marian prayer to “save us from the evil that wants to conquer the minds and souls of Poles,” namely LGBTQ equality, that included this line, “Mary, save young people seeking their identity so that they will not be seduced by fashionable slogans about freedom and tolerance, which in fact lead to enslavement and depravity.” MSN reported that the bishop previously identified banning gay men from the priesthood as a key action in ending clergy sexual abuse.

Archbishop Andrzej Dziega of Szczecin-Kamien ordered priests to read a letter at Mass on “the path of God’s truth against the path of pagan godlessness” that also picked up on Polish resistance to Nazi and Soviet occupiers. In the letter, Dziega criticized the Pride marches which have been organized in several Polish cities this year. He said the events were seeking to promote sin and to impose LGBTQ education on children in schools.

Elsewhere, Bishop Wieslaw Mering of Włocławek expressed “appreciation and admiration” for Jędraszewski because he did not “submit to political correctness” and was willing to face persecution like Jesus Christ, reported A statement of support came from Cardinal Zenon Grocholewski, former prefect of the Vatican’s Congregation for Catholic Education, as well as one from Cardinal Dominik Duka of Prague who called on bishops in Slovakia and Hungary to likewise back Krakow’s archbishop.

Fr. Pawel Gużyński may be forced to contemplate in silence for a few weeks, but one provincial’s actions cannot stop the faithful from making known their opinions to Catholic pastors for the good of the church. If you would like to send a respectful message to Archbishop Jedraszewski, Gużyński has provided the following contact information:

Mailing Address:

Ksiądz Arcybiskup Marek Jędraszewski
ul. Franciszkańska 3, 31-004 Kraków

Email:  [email protected]

Robert Shine, New Ways Ministry, August 14, 2019

7 replies
  1. Duane S Sherry
    Duane S Sherry says:

    When I read or hear words from Church leadership that seem ugly, I call on:

    1) The teachings of Christ– both His words and actions
    2) The Holy Spirit–the Advocate to find peace
    3) The conscience as a guide to discern what is right

    In short, I put the ugly words of an archbishop in perspective, pray for him, and go on…

  2. Thomas Ellison
    Thomas Ellison says:

    There is an advertisement on television for some technology product or service which uses three elderly women to demonstrate that their use of (Facebook in this case) is wholly misunderstood. One says in exasperation : “This isn’t how this works! This isn’t how any of this works!” I think that’s precisely what Jesus would make of some church hierarchical decisions.

  3. Dr. James D'Eramo
    Dr. James D'Eramo says:

    Archbishop Jędraszewski,
    Your homophobic campaign against equal civil rights for Gay People does not reflect Jesus’ Gospel message: Love One Another.
    You make a mockery of Christ and his Gospel by preaching words that inspire hatred and oppression of an entire class of God’s people.
    You insult God Himself/Herself by vilifying an entire group of human beings that He/She created.
    That is a form of blasphemy.
    You must ask yourself, “What would Jesus say about homosexuals?”
    Then, you must preach Christ’s Gospel of Love — not your message of hate.
    Yours Respectfully,
    James D’Eramo, Ph.D.

  4. Loretta
    Loretta says:

    “Under the guise of discrimination” — spin on steroids. The more the clergy defends its position the more they reveal the flaws in their reasoning.

  5. John Hilgeman
    John Hilgeman says:

    I admire the courage of these two priests in speaking out against the cruel and unchristian comments of these bishops. I hope they both have good support networks. I cannot help wondering what it is that motivates these bishops to behave in such a manner and to utter such incendiary lies about LGBT people.

  6. Joey Pugh
    Joey Pugh says:

    If the Archbishop wishes to save the souls of LGBTQ people, he will not disrespect them. If he does not wish to save them, he should not be a catholic cleric.

  7. Joseph McCarty
    Joseph McCarty says:

    I saw on the news how the right-wing group was jeering and itching to hurt the Gay Pride Day participants. As the police were shielding the L.G.B.T. group the right-wingers attacked the police. The Archbishop seems to be blaming the victim. What the Pride group exposed was the violent hate of the right-wingers. According to the news report, they are wanting to set up LGBT-free zones in Poland. This has ominous overtones of the Nazi determination to erase Jews from Poland and all of Central Europe in the 1940’s. The people of Poland and of the Church need to vigilantly defend the free speech rights. LGBT people should be welcomed back into the faith community with open arms.
    of LGBT people and to welcome them back into the faith communityOnly a concerted effort to defend values of tolerance and


Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *