Tending to the Wounds Created by the 1986 Ratzinger Letter
“Forty Years in the Desert: LGBTQ+ People and the Ratzinger Letter”

Throughout the month of October, Bondings 2.0 will publish a series entitled “Forty Years of Wandering in the Desert.” It will feature articles by Catholic theologians and thought leaders who advocate for LGBTQ+ people about the significance and impact of the Letter on church life and LGBTQ+ lives.
The negative impact the Letter had on LGBTQ+ ministry, advocacy, and lived reality cannot be overstated. It changed the entire church discourse on homosexuality for more than a generation, and it brought about major changes in church policy and practice. Marking the 40th anniversary is a way to review the damage it has done, but also to see the progress that was made in spite of it.
To read the previous four essays in this series, by James Alison, Jason Steidl Jack, Marianne Duddy-Burke, and Fr. Lucas Sharma, SJ, click here.
Today’s essay is by Annie Selak (she/her),a feminist theologian and author of The Wounded Church: Tending to the Harm within Catholicism.

Annie Selak
When something is so devastating to a community that we are still discussing it decades later, people tend to fall into two camps about how to proceed. The first camp calls for moving past it. These calls to “get over it” are often well-intentioned, aimed at not giving more attention and power to the event that caused harm. The second camp wants to address that topic head on. Some might call this dwelling on pain, but proponents of this way of action argue that we can only move forward by acknowledging the true extent of the pain.
I fall into the second camp. As a feminist theologian who studies the contemporary church, I think it is critical that we examine the church not in abstraction, but rather, with concrete experience. In fact, I suggest that we start with the sources of pain, or wounds.
In the past, I worked in gender and LGBTQ Centers on Catholic college campuses. If I asked 100 students about the “Ratzinger Letter” or “Halloween Letter,” my guess is that between 0-1 of them would know what this referred to. Yet that is part of the insidious nature of wounds: they can cause harm even if we are unaware of their origins. When I asked students about churches or faith communities, nearly all responded that these were sites of pain and exclusion. The language of “intrinsically evil” or “disordered” was well known, even if the source and context were not. The ongoing harm of this teaching continues to be felt, long beyond the awareness of the letter.
Attending to Wounds
The church is both wounded and wounder, victim and perpetrator, thus causing harm to itself. In this case, perhaps most obviously, we see the church as wounder. The Vatican’s promulgation of “Letter to the Bishops on the Pastoral Care of Homosexual Persons” caused pain to the LGBTQ+ community. Yet, the church has also been wounded by this document, for the LGBTQ+ community is a part of the church. When part of the church is excluded or harmed, the entire church suffers, for we are robbed of the fullness of the Body of Christ.
The “Halloween Letter” concretized a pain and harm that was previously felt but unnamed. By giving language and the official Vatican seal to exclusion, it created a wound in the church that is unparalleled in its scope.
In The Wounded Church: Tending to the Harm within Catholicism, I suggested that one of the mistakes that people make in discussing the church is equating it with the hierarchy. Instead, I offer a rule for talking about the church: “The church has a hierarchy; it is not a hierarchy.” When we affirm that the church was wounded by the “Halloween Letter,” we are affirming that the church is the people of God. The church is not strictly located in the Vatican or in the bishops Itis also located in home churches, local parishes, and those who have left the institutional church in pursuit of finding a loving community.
We need to do theology from the site of the wound. The pain and suffering of a community is not secondary to theology— it is a starting point. When we start from the wound, we take seriously the lived experience of the LGBTQ+ community. We can start from pain and exclusion, as well as joy and resilience. This endeavor is not a call for the glorification of suffering, but rather, the taking seriously of experience.
Avoiding a Rush to Healing
Every time I speak about wounds, a well-meaning person asks about healing. While healing is possible, a desire to rush the healing process can often cause more harm.
When a traumatic event occurs, it can split life into a “before” and an “after.” The “Ratzinger Letter” is one such event, creating such a decisive split in time that the previous “before” time is no longer accessible. This letter articulated an exclusion that was often felt just below the surface, and in doing so, created a new wave of harm.
Physical wounds can provide helpful imagery in healing. An injury to the lower back is not just contained to the few inches of the lower back. It can change the way someone walks or sits, shifting weight to the hips or overcompensating in the upper back. Physical therapy and other remedies might move the lower back towards healing, but a cold day or stumble down the stairs can bring back the pain even worse than it was before.
So, too, is it with a wound like transphobia, homophobia or the exclusion of the LGBTQ+ community. Even if the originating harm of the “Halloween Letter” is addressed, a homily or intercession rooted in negativity can bring back that originating harm in untold ways. We are always just one act away from returning to the depths of pain and suffering.
Transforming Wounds
In the Catholic faith, the originating wound isn’t the entire story. We can look to Jesus’s resurrection wounds as instructive for what healing might look like. After Jesus was crucified, died, and buried, he appeared to Mary Magdalene and then the disciples. Jesus appeared with his crucifixion wounds, yet they were transformed so that they were not actively bleeding or harming him.
Jesus could have appeared in any way he desired. He could have been a cyclone or a cloud, an apparition that mimicked what he looked like on earth or the strongest version himself. Jesus appearing with his wounds as transformed, then, can be a symbol for what healing might look like. Healing is not erasure. It is not just “moving on” and ignoring the harm. It does not downplay any harm. Jesus’s example affirms that we must address wounds and acknowledge their harm.
The pain articulated by the “Halloween Letter” continues to be felt today. Even now, the wounds of exclusion of the LGBTQ+ community continue to harm the church. Yet, the Christian faith attests that wounds can be transformed. What is needed is a similar transformation of the wounds in our church.
–Annie Selak, October 27, 2026


Avoiding a Rush to Healing

An insightful piece, thank you.
Decades ago a Carmelite priest with whom I shared my pain told me : “Christ doesn’t crucify anybody ,but the church does”. This was in the context of Ordinatio Sacerdatolis and women’s exclusion from ordination, but I also knew it was true of the treatment of the LGBTQ + community.
And If the church is the body of Christ,this wounding is self – harm.
I am grateful to Annie Selak for this clarification and profoundly sorry for the injury to the LGBTQ community. Beyond words.
Brilliant analogy, Annie. I was the emcee at Dignity’s national convention in Seattle in 1983. Close to one thousand people walked from downtown Seattle up the hill to St. James Cathedral to celebrate Mass on the last night of the convention. It was a time of great joy and promise for me personally and for Dignity USA. Flash forward to our San Francisco convention in 1989 when I was elected National President of Dignity. By then, the person who had invited us to the Cathedral on the Hill in Seattle (Archbishop Raymond Hunthausen) had been investigated by the Vatican, the Ratzinger Letter had been issued and many Dignity chapters had been evicted from their parish churches in the middle of the AIDS crisis. By the time of the Sn Francisco convention, we had literally moved from the Cathedral on the Hill to the ballroom of the Cathedral Hill Hotel in San Francisco.The theme of the 1983 Seattle Convention was Let us Build a City of God – The theme of the 1989 San Francisco convention was A Pilgrimage of Hope. In your terms, “Before and After” indeed! Our City on the Hill is still filled with the walking wounded and it is not only full of people who experienced these events firsthand but of contemporaries who are silenced in our seminaries and convents, fired in our parishes and universities and stigmatized in our trans communities. Some wounds still hurt and bleed but I am still on a pilgrimage of hope and trying to build a city of God. Faith and love will eventually resurrect a new Church. Patience, I am told, is trusting in God’s timing, not mine. Thanks again for your thoughtful and helpful article,
Many thanks for this thoughtful, beautifully constructed reflection on woundedness and recovery.