Holy Thursday: Beyond Foot-Washing

Today’s reflection is by Michaelangelo Allocca (he/him/his), a member of St. Francis Xavier parish, Manhattan, New York, and a religion teacher at St. Peter’s Prep in Jersey City, New Jersey. 

The liturgical readings for the Holy Sunday Mass of the Lord’s Supper can be found by clicking here.

Today’s reading from John’s gospel describes Jesus washing His disciples’ feet. I love this story for many reasons. One is that John is noted for his “high Christology” – his emphasis on the divinity of Jesus, starting with his gospel’s very first verse stating flatly that Jesus is God (something the other three gospels may hint at, but never actually say explicitly). Yet he is the only evangelist who tells of Jesus performing this incredible exercise in both humanity and humility.

And the foot-washing ritual we still practice today is for me one of the most powerfully moving parts of the Easter Triduum liturgy. Jesus lives out here the idea of “servant leadership,” which most of us prize. As he says, they call him “teacher” and “master,” (and I always imagine him winking as he adds, “and rightly so!”), and yet he does this act – something normally only slaves would do – for them, telling them to follow his example: “If I, therefore, the master and teacher, have washed your feet, you ought to wash one another’s feet. I have given you a model to follow, so that as I have done for you, you should also do.”

A talk about this gospel passage given by the late scripture scholar Fr. Daniel Harrington, SJ (1940-2014) introduced me to a whole new dimension to this story. Besides the widely recognized “servant leader” message, Harrington said there is another equally important lesson: the need to accept salvation on God’s terms, not our own. I had understood Peter simply as being stuck in conventional ideas about hierarchy, and perhaps the familiar phenomenon that it is sometimes more difficult to accept a kindness, than to offer one. (Have you ever turned away a compliment, rather than just saying “Thank you”?) 

Harrington suggests that Peter wants salvation on Peter’s terms, which include Jesus being superior and never humbling Himself, always being served and not being a servant. Once Jesus explains that salvation – or having an “inheritance with me,” as He phrases it here – demands abandoning those terms and accepting God’s, Peter goes overboard in the other direction with “then wash all of me!” Here I picture Jesus chuckling to Himself at how Peter still wants to control the situation, but at least now he’s doing much better than he did at first.

So if Peter had to confront his own thinking, I also have to ask, “What are my terms, and am I willing to give them up, in favor of God’s terms?” How about these: Why can’t we have a Church – and I mean now, in my lifetime – where we queer people are fully embraced as Jesus embraced all, with our love sacramentally celebrated? And since we hold no patent on being marginalized by our Church, when will women be ordained? When will our bishops do more to fight racism, perhaps enacting some of the suggestions they politely applauded and then promptly forgot about when Sr. Thea Bowman offered them well over 30 years ago? I could go on, of course, and include “terms” less high-minded than these.

And while listing some of “my terms,”I might be so bold – following Harrington’s inspiration – as to ask all of my fellow LGBTQ+ folks to examine where we cling to “our terms,” rather than God’s. We love to talk about “intersectionality,” but how well do we actually live it? I have at least two personal friends who have said, each in their own words, “I finally had to quit the church because of its unfair treatment of queer people.” 

I love both of these people fiercely, and share their anguish over our persecution. Yet I struggle mightily to repress the urge to say, “I’m sorry, but you have been able to stay through the unfair treatment of women, and people of color, and poor people, and disabled people … and only felt compelled to leave when the oppression touched you, directly?” 

I need to keep asking myself how seriously I feel the suffering of others – and try to do something about it – if I expect my suffering as a gay person to matter to other people. I frequently have to call myself on the carpet when I feel marginalized for my gayness, and remember my cis white male middle-class privilege is not erased by the one oppressed-group identity I can claim. This, to me, is part of balancing God’s terms against my terms. 

The rest of the Holy Thursday readings remind me that God’s terms apparently require me to live in a Church and a world that includes homophobia and racism and misogyny and poverty and war. Not that God wills these things to happen, but it does seem God’s will that I be living among them. These things abide as long as the fallen, fallible humans who make up the Church and world perpetuate them.. As uplifting and encouraging as the Exodus and 1 Corinthians texts from today’s liturgy are, they, too, contain reminders of this shadow side.

The Passover described in the Exodus reading is rightly celebrated as our God ending the slavery of an oppressed and suffering people. Yet it contains much evidence of disturbing elements of humanity, primarily our tendency to demonize an enemy, and to project our basest instincts onto our God. This is not the perfect, absolutely necessary, omnipotent being of Thomas Aquinas: he can’t even spot his own people without blood painted on their doors. Worse, He is guilty of genocide and gross violations of the Catholic Church’s own just-war principles. 

Our Jewish siblings recognize this paradox: at the Passover seder they spill out wine from their cups at the recitation of the ten plagues, symbolically diminishing their joy to remember that the people destroyed by these plagues were also God’s children. The ritual reminds us that we must fully confront the ugliness in human history to embrace salvation on God’s terms – that we need God to save us from sin, meaning our worst instincts.

Even the beautiful reading from 1 Corinthians, which is the oldest account of the institution of the Eucharist, delivers the mystery of grace, the free offering Jesus made – the stunning simplicity of “my body that is for you;” the “new covenant in My blood.” Paul’s almost offhand “on the night he was handed over,” reminds us that some to whom He gives His body and blood killed Him for his radical humility. And in the verses immediately before this passage, we learn that the same people ‘doing this in remembrance of Him’ are also squabbling and neglecting their poor.

In today’s readings we see that our terms – all of our human weaknesses and distorted desires – are precisely why we need the salvation offered on God’s terms. I am grateful that Dan Harrington helped me notice this, and I will bring this gratitude and awareness into my Triduum observance this year.

—Michaelangelo Allocca, April 2, 2026

7 replies
  1. Fr. Paul Morrissey, OSA
    Fr. Paul Morrissey, OSA says:

    Wow!
    How wonderful a reflection.
    Thank you for expanding the meaning of the call to acceptance,
    imaged on this day of foot-washing, even including a challenge
    to LGBTQ people who leave the church. Have a blessed Easter!

    Reply
    • Michaelangelo Allocca
      Michaelangelo Allocca says:

      Thanks so much, and you’re welcome (I have fond memories of Augustinian fathers and brothers I worked with when I lived in Chicago). Triduum blessings to you and yours.

      Reply
    • JP
      JP says:

      LGBTQ people who leave the church have the right to do so, without being blamed for it.

      One should consider themselves blessed if they haven’t had to bear the brunt of what is done to many of us by this church.And even more blessed are those who have the fortitude to stay in spite of all of it.

      No need to ‘challenge’ those who can’t, adding blame on top of trauma.

      Reply
  2. Richard Allegra
    Richard Allegra says:

    Exactly what I needed to hear. I was feeling impatient this year and just wanted to get to Easter and “move on.” This reflection gave me a fresh perspective. I’m ready to more fully enter into these important, central Three Days. Thank you.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *