Transgender Hermit Gives Parish Talk on Trans Issues
Following a postponement due to backlash and in the midst of rosary-praying protesters, the Catholic Church’s only known transgender vowed religious spoke at a Kentucky parish on transgender issues in the church.
Br. Christian Matson, the transgender hermit in the Diocese of Lexington, Kentucky, whose coming out in 2024 earned widespread attention, told those gathered in Historic St. Paul’s Catholic Church that his gender transition, his religious vocation, and his Catholic faith go hand in hand. Matson’s appearance was sponsored by the parish’s LGBTQ+ ministry and the Catholic LGBTQ+ outreach organization Fortunate Families, both led by Stan “JR” Zerkowski.

Br. Christian Matson
In addition to outlining his personal story of transition and conversion, Matson presented an argument for transgender inclusion as a component of Catholic orthodoxy. Lamenting the Vatican’s recent preoccupation with “gender ideology” — a strawman concept used by hierarchical entities to avoid complex biological reality — Matson said that Vatican documents, particularly 2024’s Dignitas Infinita and 2019’s “Male and Female He Created Them,” mischaracterize the views and experiences of transgender Catholics. Transgender Catholics, said Matson, “believe in the goodness of God.”
“We believe in God’s creation, and we understand that how we are made is how we’re made by God, and it is good,” the hermit continued. “God creates a diversity of experiences that are more complex than we’ve yet felt free to deal with in the church.”
An Oxford University-trained theologian, Matson expressed confidence in the compatibility of Catholic anthropology and transgender inclusion. Acknowledging the inadequacy of the church’s pastoral and intellectual response to transgender lives, is not, Matson said, “in any way a confrontation or a challenge of Catholic anthropology.” He explained:
“Yes, male and female He created them. Yes, it is good. Yes, human beings are made for self giving. Yes, the body is important theologically. And we are a mind-body unity, which, by the way, is why it’s so important for people to transition because the unity of the mind and the body are important.”
Some might be surprised, Matson said, to learn that he has profound esteem for St. Pope John Paul II’s Theology of the Body, a series of lectures about sexuality and gender which defend traditional Catholic views. Those writings have influenced his own intellectual and religious convictions about sex, gender and the human person:
“Now, there are legitimate critiques. I’m not going to say there aren’t, but I used it in my Ph.D dissertation. You know, I love the idea of us being made to give ourselves to others.”
Matson, an adult convert, said he would not have become Catholic — much less pursue religious life and endure the all-too-common rejections — if he did not firmly believe in the supreme teaching authority of the Roman Catholic Church. Indeed, along with his thirst for the Eucharistic Lord, his conviction that the church was what is said it was spurred his conversion:
“After a few years I realized I was trying to think about what options in my life were open to me depending on whether or not I believed that the Catholic Church had the authority it claimed to have, or whether I decided it didn’t. My next thought was ‘I think it does have that authority’. My next thought was ‘I’ve got to become Catholic.’”
It is precisely that love and respect for the church, colored by his expertise and lived experience, that empowers Matson to critique official handling of transgender issues in a spirit of love and service.
“I love the Church. It would be so much easier for me to be an Episcopalian, but I stay here because of the Eucharist. I believe in the authority of the Church. I don’t challenge statements like “Male and Female He Created Them” because I think the Church is bad. I challenge them because I believe that the process by which they were created was not a process that yields truth.”
—Jeromiah Taylor, New Ways Ministry, May 30, 2025
Editor’s note: This post was updated on May 30, 2025, to reflect the event’s sponsorship by Historic St. Paul Catholic Church and Fortunate Families.




Thank you Brother Christian for your courage and perspective. Thank you Jeromiah for your reporting. The Church needs to hear from all our members. Peace and every good!
One article I read about him said he was writing a book about these topics, I’m hoping he updates us on that!
Book in progress! Manuscript is due at the end of the year. Please pray for me!
https://www.paypal.com/donate?campaign_id=DHJT49LLQQPHA
Thank you Brother Christian for all you do. I am a transgender Catholic and feel a call to Vocation. I don’t know if it will happen for me but God has given me hope through you. I’m so grateful your talk was able to proceed! I look forward to your book and will pray for you.
Jamie check out the mercy of God community (www.mgc.org)- we have had and have trans folk involved in the community – either as vowed or associate affiliation.
Peace and all good.
Thank you, Joe! As it turns out I have found my vocation as a Secular Franciscan! I am currently attending local fraternity meetings and hoping to apply for formation as soon as I am able. Pax et bonum!
Brother Christian,
Thank you for your life of love for God and love for people. You inspire by living your authentic life. Teresa of Avila said ” Do what brings you to love.” You show how, when we do, we are the people God created us to be-thank you!