Activist Jamie Manson On Why the Suffering of LGBTQ People and Women Keeps Her Going

Jamie Manson

LGBTQ Nation recently profiled queer Catholic activist Jamie Manson, who shared why she stays in the struggle for greater justice and equality in the church, even when it can be trying to do so at times. Manson, who was just named president of Catholics for Choice after serving as an editor and columnist at the National Catholic Reporter for many years, named the suffering of so many LGBTQ people and women as her motivation when the work seems overwhelming. She said:

“On my bad days… [I stay] because I see the power that the institutional church has over the lives of LGBTQ people and women, and it’s harmful and menacing… This institution has enormous global power, and you can’t look away from that. So on my tougher days, I’m like, no this thing is a force and a force for enormous harm for women and for LGBTQ people, so I have to keep fighting and raising that awareness.’ . . .

“‘Women and people of marginalized genders and queer people are suffering at the hands of pervasive, globally influential Catholic doctrine. So if I get down, I think about the suffering, and that keeps me going. It really does.'”

The work of building up equality in the church can be tiring. While there are many bright spots today, like the growing number of welcoming parishes and Germany’s Synodal Way, global progress towards a truly inclusive Catholic Church remains slow. And just being LGBTQ and Catholic can be exhausting, too. No one should ever feel compelled to stay in the church if it is too harmful or it is stifling one’s relationship with God. But for those of us who do remain, Manson’s words can be sustenance in our own hard times. Indeed, perhaps one of the most Catholic things to do is to be called into service by the suffering of others.

Robert Shine, New Ways Ministry, January 2, 2020

2 replies
    DON E SIEGAL says:

    Activist Jamie Manson On Suffering

    I would agree that the institutional church does woeful harm to women, especially those with postgraduate degrees and the queer community. But their harm is not limited to those members. The institutional church also condemns and harms heterosexuals who get divorced and remarry without an annulment, and they do likewise to heteronormative couples by telling them how and when to have sex.

    It’s going to take the virtue of fortitude on the part of the enlightened few in the institutional church and us to bring about change.

  2. cheryl rogers
    cheryl rogers says:

    Thank you for keeping up the ‘good fight’ for all of us!

    But I continue to struggle with why or why can’t the Catholic Church walk and talk in the way of Christ? Why have they fallen into power issues and control on this issue especially. Where is the hospitality of Christ with the Church with the LBGTQ people of faith? Where is the message that all are welcomed? Unconditionally means without the conditions put upon us by what now seems more like a private club, then an all inclusive
    Catholic Church which is talked about but not lived. Sometimes the double standards and the hypocrisy are oh too much for this old soul. May God help us all.


Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *