For Lesbian Visibility Day, Swiss Theologian Writes on Church’s Dual Discrimination

Susanne Birke

In an open letter from Switzerland, Catholic theologian Susanne Birke shared her experience as a “woman-loving female” for Lesbian Visibility Day, which took place on April 26th. Birke published her letter on the website of the Global Network of Rainbow Catholics.

In 2013, Birke came out publicly in the Diocese of Basel, where she serves as a theologian. Her peers and colleagues at the grassroots level were supportive, even though the institutional church continues to be oppressive. She wrote:

“So yes, in a way it feels crazy, working for a Church, who not only discriminates against me because of my genitals, but also because of whom I love. But I love my church too much to leave it in the hands of those who would rather see people like me gone. I met many wonderful human beings all around the world, doing great work in many ways. This means more to me than the discrimination I experience. And last, but not least: no matter, what will happen, I will remain part of the «resurrection movement» that started 2000 years ago.” 

Birke wrote that she often endured and witnessed this sexism and homophobia in the church at a structural level. She noticed that Catholic men “felt they had a right to tell [her] what to do.” Eventually she learned that working to gain acceptance “as a woman by a male-dominated upper level is not easy.”  In the LGBT community, lesbian issues are often not recognized and are usually underfunded, she said. 

Birke has been part of the Diocese of Basel’s Rainbow Ministry. Throughout her years of LGBT work, she has noticed a shift towards inclusion. She commented that,

“The [church] reform movement in Switzerland is extraordinarily strong and there are strong women’s organisations and networks too. The Swiss Catholic Women’s League is the biggest Roman Catholic organisation here and supports marriage equality.”

Birke’s personal testimony reminds us that lesbian women are still treated with systemic prejudice and inequality, especially within the church at large. Despite the injustice, she expressed strong words of hope we can all take to heart: “Do not let anybody stop you from combining something in the core of your being, because others think it is impossible. You might be here to open new doors!”

Emily Win, May 7, 2020

3 replies
  1. Anton
    Anton says:

    Yes, Birke is right ON! The readings of Mass this week show us how the church opened up to Gentiles. The same process is going on now in regard to LGBTQ persons. “What God has declared clean, we dare not call UNclean!” Peter on the roof of Joppa. The Spirit bloweth where She willeth” and we just trim our sails to take us where She sends us.
    Thank you Birke!! And all who are “listening = obeying” the Spirit.

  2. Patricia Vasilj
    Patricia Vasilj says:

    I am a Mom and a cradle Catholic. I love my son very much and saw what the Church has done to him. I understand how the author feels. It would be easier to just walk away but there is something about the Church that still draws me to it. But I can not reconcile what the Church has done to damage the psyche of LBGTQ individuals. To equate God’s love for His children and the condemnation of Church leaders wears on one, especially a Mom. Hurt my son, hurt me. I had a pastor once who said he had to remind himself he was not God. I would say that advice is one that should be practiced by all of us, including the Catholic Church.


Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.