U.S. Bishops “Gravely Disappointed” with Equality Act, Support Trump’s Anti-Transgender Guideline

Cardinal Timothy Dolan promoting U.S. bishops religious liberty campaign in 2012

The U.S. bishops have continued to support the Trump administration’s erosion of rights for LGBTQ people, this time decrying the Equality Act’s recent passage in by the House of Representatives and endorsing a new federal anti-transgender guideline. Catholics are again left wondering just how far Church leaders will go in their crusade which they describe as protecting religious liberty but which shows little concern for LGBTQ lives.

On May 17th, five top U.S. bishops, in their capacity as chairs of episcopal conference committees, released a statement claiming they were “gravely disappointed” that the Equality Act, which would enshrine LGBTQ non-discrimination protections into federal law, had passed the House. The bishops’ commented:

“Rather than offering meaningful protections for individuals, the Equality Act would impose sweeping new norms that negatively impact the unborn, health care, charitable services, schools, personal privacy, athletics, free speech, religious liberties, and parental rights. The Act’s unsound definitions of ‘sex’ and ’gender identity’ would erase women’s distinct, hard-won recognition in federal laws. Its sex-based nondiscrimination terms would end women’s shelters and many single-sex schools. It would close faith-based foster care and adoption agencies that honor children’s rights to a mother and father. The bill would even act as an abortion mandate. We must pursue justice and equality for anyone denied it; but this is a regrettable approach.”

The bishops issuing the statement were Kansas City, Kansas’ Archbishop Joseph Naumann, chair of the Committee on Pro-Life Activities; Louisville’s Archbishop Joseph Kurtz, chair of the Committee for Religious Liberty; Venice, Florida’s Bishop Frank Dewane, chair of the Committee on Domestic Justice and Human Development; Lincoln Nebraska’s Bishop James Conley, chair of the Subcommittee for the Promotion and Defense of Marriage; and Oakland, California’s Bishop Michael Barber, chair of the Committee on Catholic Education. Previously, Church leaders have written that the Equality Act would be a “detriment to society as a whole” and would have “devastating consequences” for religious liberty.

These bishops, minus Barber, issued another statement on May 24th applauding the Trump administration’s latest assault on transgender rights. The bishops expressed gratitude for the Department of Health and Human Services’ (HHS) proposed guidelines that would prohibit “sex” from being interpreted as inclusive of “gender identity” and thereby erase trans healthcare protections which President Barack Obama had sought to implement. Earlier this month, Naumann and Kurtz celebrated another set of HHS guidelines that would allow healthcare providers to deny care to LGBTQ people if such denial is based in the provider’s religious beliefs.

As of May 26th, the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops had posted six policy-related statements to its website for the month of May: one gently chiding the Trump administration for its most recent immigration proposal, one celebrating the passage of anti-choice laws in states like Alabama, and four opposing LGBTQ rights.

Is there a point when the U.S. bishops will reevaluate their unyielding religious liberty campaign which aligns them with the Trump administration’s worst anti-LGBTQ impulses, even if unintentionally? One test case involves proposed guidelines from the Department of Housing and Urban Development that would allow religiously-affiliated, federally-funded shelters for people experiencing homelessness to discriminate against transgender clients. If approved, these guidelines would further inhibit an already difficult situation for trans people without stable housing, reported The Washington Post:

“One in three transgender people have experienced homelessness — including one in eight in the last year alone, putting them at risk of physical and sexual violence and being forced into sex work, according to the National Center for Transgender Equality.

“Seventy percent of transgender people who tried going to a shelter in the last year were kicked out for being transgender, were physically or sexually assaulted, or faced another form of mistreatment because of their gender identity, the center said.”

It is unclear if the bishops will release a statement on the proposed homeless shelter guidelines, too.

Given the range of social injustices under Trump that the bishops should be focused on–like caged children at the U.S.-Mexico border and climate change–their focus on religious liberty at the expense of LGBTQ civil rights appears narrowly and obsessively focused. The bishops risk abandoning the very faith tradition which they are tasked with upholding, a tradition that prioritizes solidarity with the marginalized as a Gospel mandate. Catholics must keep vocally and vigorously defending LGBTQ civil rights because, once again, our bishops clearly are not.

Robert Shine, New Ways Ministry, May 30, 2019

8 replies
  1. Tom Bower
    Tom Bower says:

    It is sad they wear the garb that is supposed to identify themselves as bringers of peace and love. Classic definition of hypocrisy.

  2. Mary Jo
    Mary Jo says:

    Tax exemption should be stripped of this church and many others as well. But, at the very least, if you feel compelled to remain in this church, stop giving it your hard earned money! They are using it against you!

  3. Elizabeth Linehan
    Elizabeth Linehan says:

    I am appalled at these bishops’ position, and their arguments. “Religious liberty,” it seems, does not extend to the consciences of individual persons. Some individual persons affected by discrimination based on sexual orientation or gender identity are not Catholics to begin with. Why ever would they rely on these bishops’ understanding of sexuality and gender?

  4. John Hilgeman
    John Hilgeman says:

    Frédéric Martel has done a great service for the Church, in unmasking the ugliness of self-hatred hiding beneath the antigay, anti-trans policies and doctrines of the Roman Catholic hierarchy. Hierarchical opposition to any and every bit of legal progress toward the equality of LGBT people in this country, and in many other countries, has been an incessant and wide-spread (with few notable exceptions) attack on the equality and worth of LGBT people. How much of that opposition in our own country has been the fruit of self-hatred?

    And the attempt to use the opposition of rights for transgender people as a front for the defense of women, is priceless, from a group of men whose doctrines exclude women from full equality in the Church.

    The men who issue these statements in support of a president whose policies and actions have been so harmful to so many people in our nation, are writing their own history of harm and damage to the very people they attack and the people whose value they demean.

    Fortunately, a couple of the recent stories on this site have highlighted the actions of others in the Church who are willing to speak out and oppose the actions of such leaders. Many people have been walking away from the RCC as a result of such actions. But many of those who stay have been either ignoring such actions, or confronting them for the evil that they are.

  5. Sarasi
    Sarasi says:

    “The Act’s unsound definitions of ‘sex’ and ’gender identity’ would erase women’s distinct, hard-won recognition in federal laws.”

    As if the bishops had a drop of interest in or sympathy for women’s rights and don’t constantly badmouth feminism. I don’t know what has happened to these folks but they also spend far too much of their time on “defence of marriage,”–something they never actually experienced and never will, and just more code for anti-LGBTQ equality. They are steadily eroding their own relevance.

  6. Paula Mattras
    Paula Mattras says:

    What ever happened to “love one another as I have loved you?” Or, “do unto others as you would have them do unto you?”
    Or, “but the greatest of these is love?”
    I just want to know.

  7. Rita Cotterly
    Rita Cotterly says:

    Until the Bishops study human sexuality seriously and over an extended length of time, they will continue making decisions on incorrect information. It is embarrassing that they are so ignorant concerning human nature which is in the image of God, our Creator. It is tragic for all of the LGBT individuals and their families who suffer so much because of the Bishop’s lack of knowledge.

  8. Mark F Clark
    Mark F Clark says:

    When they get a few women in their number, policies will move decidedly in a saner direction. Think of how the growing femalization of Congress has improved that place.


Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *