Why I Left, Why I Stay: ‘Jesus Had Been In My Heart All Along”

In DecemberBondings 2.0  invited readers to share the stories of their relationship with the Catholic Church by writing on the theme of “Why We Came, Why We Left, Why We Stayed.”  We “borrowed” this topic from a feature that Commonweal magazine published recently.  We felt it was important for LGBTQ people to share their own stories, so we made the invitation to our readers.

We asked contributors to keep their contributions under 500 words, and also asked how they would like to be identified in terms of name and gender/sexual identity, location.  Anonymity was offered as an option.

We received many responses, and we will be posting a selection of them them over the next few months  on Sundays (barring any important breaking news).  Many thanks to all the contributors.

To read all the previous posts in this series, click here, or click on “Why We Came. Why We Left. Why We Stayed” in the Categories section of the right-hand column of this page.


Name:  Carlos

Identified: LGBT

Why I Left, Why I Stay:  ‘Jesus Had Been In My Heart All Along’

I was brought up in a very conservative Catholic family in one of the most conservative cities in Mexico. I left the Church when I came out at 14 in the year 2000 because, in the way I had been educated, it was impossible to reconcile being a homosexual and a Catholic simultaneously. My parents –distinguished leaders within the Catholic community in our city– claimed that I had no dignity because I had a homosexual orientation. A large part of my local community and my family ostracized me. Given that I did note experience Christianity from those who claimed to be righteous ones, I chose what was to me the evident path.

I came back because, even though I had left the Church, Jesus never left me, despite the fact that I had denied him. Once I had enough freedom not to feel restrained by a certain society’s mindset, I could reconcile the idea of being a Catholic homosexual, which is fundamentally not an oxymoron. This freedom allowed my spirit to realize that Jesus had been in my heart all along, and so the right thing to do became clear, little by little.

“Conversion on St. Paul on the Road to Damascus” by Caravaggio

My return to church has not been an immediate process, but rather a lengthy one. I did not wake up one day thinking: “Oh! Of course, I have to go to Mass, confess, and pretend nothing ever happened! All of the Church’s teachings and doings are unequivocally God’s command.”  No Paul of Tarsus, I did not hear any voice, I did not see any light. And, like St. Ignatius, I did not have a powerful conversion after one year in exile. It took me about five years from the time I started attending Mass again until the time I took communion. And it is still and ongoing process. But I know deep inside that any struggle between my heart and my mind will be reconciled through prayer and practice. I might not understand some things now, but whenever the time is right the Holy Spirit will open my ears, my eyes, and my heart. And I also know that God loves me no matter what!

In the end, religious experience is far bigger than sexual orientation. And Catholicism has a lot more to offer than just rejection or acceptance of homosexuals. The Church is composed by humans and, hence, prone to error. Just think of some of the horrors perpetrated by some of the members of the clerical hierarchy. Those mistakes span from sexual issues to economic, political, spiritual ones, among others. It is up to all of us to keep the Church on the right track, and that requires hard work because we believe in the teachings of our Savior, who needlessly humbled himself for others, and we should follow His example.

I have a calling as a lay man, and I will respond both in prayer and in action. I am not going anywhere else, I am here to stay!

Carlos, February 3, 2019

5 replies
  1. Alexei
    Alexei says:

    Beautiful, Carlos,
    And thank you for your insight and sharing. What you expressed, as I read it, is very much in keeping with what Brian McLaren says in his book THE GREAT SPIRITUAL MIGRATION. I recommend it if/when you need affirmation of your journey.
    Peace and love to you,

  2. Ron
    Ron says:

    Hi Carlos: I hope your family and friends have all reconciled with the fact that you are gay and will always be gay and a Catholic as well. I hope your church invites you into the various ministries available to all. Who knows, you may find that certain person, fall in love and hope that your parents will accept him as they accept you. You are a blessed man and how great it is you are back into the church and receiving the Sacraments. God bless you and your future. Ron

  3. Charles
    Charles says:

    Excellent testimony all around. Great recognition of the Church’s balance between its sinful humanity and its divine image. A model to which we are all called to strive.

  4. Akexei
    Akexei says:

    Thanks again, Carlos, and all others who are sharing their stories. It reminds me of today’s gospel – the driving out of the Legion of demons into the pigs. What a recipe for deviled ham! LOL Jesus freed the man from his demons and told him to stay to let his family and friends know about it. That’s us LGBTQ people: we’re freed from our demons/accepted by Jesus/God and told to stay in the church to keep proclaiming our release and helping others to trust in God’s love and liberation.
    God’s liberating Spirit is greater than legions of demons and a unties all the shackles.
    Peace and love,


Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *