Sr. Joan Chittister Hopes Pope Francis Can Dispel Catholic Weariness Through Listening

Sister Joan Chittister

Sister Joan Chittister

Pope Francis was officially inaugurated earlier this morning, concluding much of the ceremonial introductions and beginning his papacy in full. A week of speculation and observation leaves Catholics and the world-at-large with a growing understanding of who this pope is, from where he emerges as former head of the Argentine church, and where the Church might be heading. Sister Joan Chittister, a Benedictine nun writing in National Catholic Reporter, discusses weariness on the part of many Catholics and her desire for Pope Francis to sincerely listen.

Referencing a column by Pat Howard, a local journalist near her Erie, Pennsylvania, monastery, Sr. Joan identifies the problem afflicting Catholics:

“It is weariness that is palpable in so many groups now…

“Weariness comes from a soul whose hope has been disappointed one time too many. To be weary is not a condition of the body — that’s tiredness. No, weariness is a condition of the heart that has lost the energy to care anymore.”

After a papacy under Benedict XVI that denied modern developments in the hierarchy’s understandings and suppressed even posing questions, many are left weary, which in Sr. Joan’s eyes is worse than anger or indifference:

“People are weary of hearing more about the laws of the church than the love of the Jesus who says whatever a person’s struggles, ‘Remember, I am with you always’ (Matthew 28:20).

“People are weary of seeing whole classes of people — women, gays and even other faith communities again — rejected, labeled, seen as ‘deficient,’ crossed off the list of the acceptable…

“It gets spiritually exhausting to go on waiting for a pastor again and instead getting a scolding, reactionary church whose idea of perfection is the century before the last one rather than the century after this one…

“All in all, they’re weary of being told, ‘Don’t even think about it.’ They’re weary of being treated as if they are bodies and souls without a brain.”

Weariness is so subversive, and thus worrisome for Sr. Joan, because it undercuts caring, and people will not react with anger for change or endure hardship in hope that the situation will improve.  Weariness just kills the weary one’s interest. However, in Sr. Joan’s eyes, Pope Francis provides an opportunity to give rest to the weary if he acts pastorally. Of his first appearance as pope,, she writes:

“And then came the real shock: He bowed to the people. Bowed. And asked them to pray a blessing down on him before he blessed them. Francis, I remembered, was the Christian who reached out to Muslims. Francis, the one who listened to every creature in the universe and dialogued with it.

“Indeed, if this Francis, too, is a listener, there is hope for reconciliation, hope for healing, hope for the development of the church.

“No doubt about it: We know who the people are who have been waiting for a pope and why they are weary. The question now is, Does he know how weary they are? And does he care? Really?”

The LGBT community, families, and advocates are certainly counted among Sr. Joan’s weary Catholics who suffer from a hierarchy intent on legalism and rejection. Many of us continue to practice the faith for reasons unique to each person, fluctuating perhaps between bouts of weariness and bursts of energy.

Pope Francis’ previous statements on LGBT rights are clear, his record on marriage equality less so–and neither are good. With the inaugural Mass concluded, and many ‘firsts’ completed, now Pope Francis must begin governing with, not over, the People of God. We can echo Sr. Joan’s words that “Maybe, just maybe, this time…” there will be change enough to dispel some weariness if this new papacy commences in a listening posture.

–Bob Shine, New Ways Ministry

0 replies
  1. ermadurk
    ermadurk says:

    Again, Sr. Joan, has “hit the nail on the head.” I let go of bits and pieces of my weariness when our new Pope Francis speaks of service (awareness) to the poorest, the least, the neediest, the land. The heavy pressure of weariness lightens when I see him choose simplicity, and I witness his eagerness to show his respect to “the people.” However, now, my weariness is struggling with my wariness. I have had a glimpse of Pope Francis’ tenderness, now I hope and pray he will have the inner ferocity (like a sheep dog!) to listen to, and protect the weary who long for change within our Church, as well as in the world.

  2. Ryan Sattler
    Ryan Sattler says:

    Once again, the right message at the right moment. For I am being asked by so many Catholic friends, will this Francis be any different? If the Holy Spirit was working through the conclave, then we must be patient, we must be hopeful, we must be open to the holiest of possibilities.

  3. jconnolly
    jconnolly says:

    I truly believe that we how have Pope Francis, just as we had the last 2 popes chosen by the Holy Spirit for our times. Pope Francis has shown his love for the poor and downtrodden. He will no doubt live this sacred Gospel imperative and set a great example, as he passes on the Sacred Deposit of the Faith unadulterated to renew all members of the Church, while giving a voice to the voiceless.

    As a gay man, I have never witnessed, experienced, nor grown weary of “whole classes of people — women, gays and even other faith communities… rejected, labeled, seen as ‘deficient,’ crossed off the list of the acceptable.” I frankly don’t know what Sr. Chittister is talking about.

    The Catholic Church has become the true counterculture of our times. When needed, it has stood up for the Truth that doesn’t change, in the face of the relativism that is destroying Western culture. If this is seen as “scolding, reactionary,” amidst a total absence of moral consensus, so be it. We now have a wonderfully humble, holy man to shepherd Christ’s Church. The Holy Spirit will express the will of Christ for the barque of Peter through Pope Francis. Let us rejoice abundantly and be glad! Far from being wearied, I am elated, just as I was when Benedict XVI became the Bishop of Rome. There are no accidents.


Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *