Extreme Protests from Both Sides of the Catholic Marriage Equality Debate

Two protests occurred in Europe over the weekend regarding Catholic involvement in the question of marriage equality.  One protest was for marriage equality and one was against it. Both were extreme.

article-protest4-0113The pro-marriage equality protest took place in St. Peter’s Square in Vatican City,  when four women went topless to demonstrate against the Catholic hierarchy’s opposition to marriage for lesbian and gay couples and adoption of children by same-gender couples.

The New York Daily News reports

“While the pope was giving his weekly address on Sunday, four women from the Ukrainian Femen group who were in the crowd, pulled off their T-shirts to reveal the slogan ‘In Gay we Trust’ painted over their bodies.”

The same Femen group staged a protest appearing as topless nuns in Paris a few months ago, which erupted in a violent clash between two demonstrating groups.

An Italian court had recently issued a ruling allowing for a mother and her female partner to maintain custody of a son, depsite the father’s protest against such an arrangement:

“The Court of Cassation ruled it was ‘mere prejudice’ to assume that living with a homosexual couple could be detrimental for a child’s development

“While gay rights group Arcigay called it a ‘historic ruling’ for Italy, where it is illegal for gay couples to adopt, Catholic leaders were quick to defend the traditional family unit.”

In the United Kingdom, 1,054 Roman Catholic priests and 13 bishops and abbots signed a public letter protesting the move in that nation toward legalizing marriage equality.  The Daily Telegraph reports:

“More than 1,000 priests have signed a letter voicing alarm that same-sex marriage could threaten religious freedom in a way last seen during ‘centuries of persecution’ of Roman Catholics in England.

“They even liken David Cameron’s moves to redefine marriage to those of Henry VIII, whose efforts to secure a divorce from Katherine of Aragon triggered centuries of bloody upheaval between church and state.”

The news report notes that the signers account for one-quarter of  all the Catholic priests in England and Wales.  Of course, that means that three-quarters of the priests did not sign the statement.

Both cases illustrate a minority of the people who promote or oppose marriage equality, and their extreme actions and rhetoric add nothing to the debate, but simply inflame passions.

See also: Gay Star News:  Italian Catholic Church likens gay parenting to selling children.

–Francis DeBernardo, New Ways Ministry

0 replies
  1. S.Waugh
    S.Waugh says:

    With all due respect, were it not for the extreme actions of the drag queens at Stonewall or the desperate screaming of ACT UP, attention may never have been drawn to both of these crisis issues. I applaud and support the action of those Femen group. Perhaps there extreme behavior will cause enough attention to set the pontif back on his well prada’d heels. Trying to “dialog” has gotten us no where with the boys in Rome or the NCCB. Sometimes you need to get ones attention first before you can move forward in a new and different direction.

  2. Terri Hemker
    Terri Hemker says:

    As the Catholic mother of a gay transgendered man, I agree with S. Waugh! And God Forbid if any of those anti gay morons said something bad about or did something to MY kid!!! I would be on them like white on rice and THEN they’d find out what ‘extreme action’ really is!


Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. […] January 14, 2013: Extreme Protests from Both Sides of the Catholic Marriage Equality Debate […]

  2. […] Four days ago, we posted about two protests about Catholic involvement in marriage equality–one for marriage and one against marriage for lesbian and gay couples.  The “pro” protest involved women going topless in St. Peter’s Square in Vatican City; the “con” protest was a letter of inflated rhetoric on religious liberty signed by 1,000 priests in England and Wales. […]

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *