A Lesson to Be Learned from Marriage Equality Victories

The news is almost too incredible to believe.

Yesterday, marriage equality was made the law of the land in three states–Maine, Maryland, and Washington State–and a proposed constitutional ban against marriage equality in a fourth state–Minnesota–was defeated.

Catholics played a significant role in all four states.  In Maine, Maryland, and Washington State, the original laws that were upheld by the referendum were all signed by Catholic governors.  In those states and Minnesota, active groups of Catholics for Marriage Equality worked tirelessly to get out the vote.

What makes the efforts of these Catholics for Marriage Equality so significant is that they have worked against incredible odds.  In each case, Catholic bishops have worked against marriage equality, and their power and influence is formidable when it comes to election campaigns.

It’s not the moral authority that the bishops have.  Indeed, due to the sexual abuse crisis among other things, their moral authority has seriously decreased in the last decade.  What they do have though is a vast communication infrastructure:  parishes, sermons, letters, mailing lists, bulletin inserts, schools–these are incredibly powerful tools to mobilize voters to vote the way the bishops instruct.  Despite these advantages, the bishop failed.

The lesson of this election for Catholics interested in LGBT equality is that lay organizing is becoming more powerful than the bishops’ organizing.  Despite that lay organizers do not have the access to Catholics that the bishops have, they have found a variety of methods to get their message across:  public vigils, YouTube videos, community forums, and newspaper advertisements, to name only a few.

We’ve also seen that having courageous priests and religious who are not afraid to speak out for equality are emerging.  Their witness gives us hope that others will soon step forward to urge people to form and follow their consciences with regard to marriage equality.

May the victories today inspire Catholics to continue to work for justice and equality for LGBT people.

–Francis DeBernardo, New Ways Ministry

11 replies
  1. Joe Geist
    Joe Geist says:

    Yes, there was a bright light at the end of that tunnel. I hope the bishops are learning that there are thinking Catholics out there in the pews. Equality is not a word we use only when it is convenient.

  2. bjmonda
    bjmonda says:

    Dear Frank,
    Thank you and everyone at New Ways for your tireless efforts on behalf of Justice for all people. If I could manage it I’d give you all the Nobel Prize! You deserve it!

  3. Drew and Kathleen Conneen
    Drew and Kathleen Conneen says:

    Thank you Frank, Jeannine, Newways Ministry and all your support staff for being so instrumental in the success of Marriage Equality. God bless you for your ministry.

  4. Jerry
    Jerry says:

    It is becoming increasingly obvious: “The Church” is NOT against gay marriage – BISHOPS are against gay marriage. Unfortunately, that means the bishops are not listening to the Church. Perhaps someday they will recognize that the Holy Spirit also operates outside of the Vatican.

    Thank you, Frank and NWM, for a job continually well-done!

  5. Terence Weldon
    Terence Weldon says:

    Thanks for the important observation that lay Catholics’ organizing ability is becoming at least comparable to that of the bishops. (I’m not sure that it is yet more powerful – but that will come). You leave out one important vehicle for that organizing though – the blogosphere, to which you and I contribute, alongside so many other lgbt/ queer . straight ally Catholics and other Christians.


Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. […] his opposition to marriage equality in a flurry of tangential arguments. His view is one which Minnesota voters rejected last November; and the state’s legislature approved equal marriage rights this […]

  2. […] lay support aids marriage equality victories in Maine, Maryland, Minnesota, and Washington State. […]

  3. […] A Lesson to Be Learned from Marriage Equality Victories […]

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *